Cleveland to North Randall Village
Ohio municipal income tax, Chapter 718 framework · credit set by Cleveland ordinance · tax year 2026
Work city takes
2.75%
North Randall Village, on income earned there
Home city charges
2.5%
Cleveland, residents
Credit back
$1,500
capped by the ceiling
Cost of the commute
$150
a year, above working at home
What it costs you
ceiling bindsCleveland's credit stops at its ceiling, so the rest of its own tax still applies. Solid is what you pay; the faded part of the Cleveland bar is the credit it hands back. Municipal income tax only — state, federal and payroll tax apply on top, and an Ohio school district income tax may too.
What this commute actually costs
- Cleveland does credit you for the tax North Randall Village takes. It just stops early. The credit cannot pass about 2.5% of your income, and North Randall Village charges more than that, so it runs out before the bill does. Working there costs $150 a year more than working at home would. All in, local tax is $1,650.
- This is the only route into North Randall Village large enough to show up in the data. About 1,839 people travel it from Cleveland. Other people commute there too. Their numbers are simply too small to be counted separately.
- Roughly 1,839 people travel from Cleveland to North Randall Village for work. Multiply one household's answer by that, and the credit rule stops being a detail.
- The credit here is real but bounded. Cleveland allows residents about 100% of tax paid to another municipality, subject to a ceiling of about 2.5% of income, and on this pairing it is the ceiling rather than the share that binds. North Randall Village withholds $1,650 at about 2.75%; Cleveland returns $1,500 of that and collects the remainder of its own about 2.5% resident levy. The workplace accordingly costs $150 above the home-only position, against a total of $1,650.
- Within this dataset North Randall Village draws a single recorded commuting flow of qualifying size — the one from Cleveland, carrying roughly 1,839 workers. That reflects the reporting floor rather than the labor market: smaller flows certainly exist and fall below the threshold at which Census origin-destination statistics are published. No ranking against sibling routes is therefore available for this workplace.
- Census origin-destination statistics record approximately 1,839 workers commuting from Cleveland to North Randall Village, placing this among the larger intra-state flows in Ohio. The outcome set out above therefore has aggregate fiscal consequence for both municipalities, not merely individual consequence for the worker: the credit Cleveland does or does not extend is applied to every one of them at once.
Where the money goes
A $75,000 salary
- Federal income tax$7,670
- Social Security and Medicare$5,738
- State income tax$1,346
- Yours$60,246
| Federal income tax10.23% | $7,670 |
|---|---|
| Social Security and Medicare7.65% | $5,738 |
| State income tax1.79% | $1,346 |
| Yours80.33% | $60,246 |
The arithmetic, step by step
| North Randall Village takes, on income earned there | $1,650 |
|---|---|
| Cleveland charges residents | $1,500 |
| Less the credit Cleveland gives back | $1,500 |
| Total local tax | $1,650 |
| If you also lived in North Randall Village | $1,500 |
| Difference | $150 |
On a reference salary of $60,000 a year. Both rates and the credit ceiling are shares of income, so every figure scales with your own pay.
What this page does not cover
- Two guesses about this are wrong, and they miss in opposite directions. The rates are not added together. Nor do you simply pay whichever is higher, which is how it works across the border in Pennsylvania. North Randall Village taxes what you earn there, Cleveland taxes everything you earn, and then Cleveland decides how much of the first bill to give back.
- One thing to keep in mind. Ohio does not require Cleveland to give any credit at all. That choice sits with the city, and cities revisit it. A vote in Cleveland could change what this commute to North Randall Village costs you, with no change in the law itself.
- Ohio has a second local tax that is not on this page. Some school districts levy their own income tax. It depends on where you live, not on your job in North Randall Village, and the credit from Cleveland does not touch it. If your district charges one, add it to everything here.
- Do not read this as your whole tax bill. It is the part that answers to the commute between Cleveland and North Randall Village. State and federal tax carry on regardless, unchanged by which side of a city line your desk is on.
- The dollar figures rest on one assumed salary, sixty thousand. Double your pay and they double. Halve it and they halve. What stays put is the relationship between what North Randall Village charges and what Cleveland gives back, which is the part worth carrying away.
- Two misreadings bracket the correct answer and both are common. Ohio does not simply add the two rates together, which would overstate the charge; nor does it apply only the higher of them, which is Pennsylvania's rule and would understate it wherever the credit is partial. North Randall Village taxes what is earned within its boundaries, Cleveland taxes its residents on everything, and Cleveland then credits some, all or none of what North Randall Village collected. The credit is the entire mechanism, and it is set by Cleveland rather than by the state.
- The credit rule modeled here is Cleveland's own, adopted by ordinance and amendable by Cleveland alone. Ohio's uniform framework governs definitions, filing and withholding; it does not compel any municipality to credit tax paid to another. A council vote in Cleveland can therefore change every figure on this page without anything altering in North Randall Village or in state law, which is a materially different exposure from a rate set by statute.
- Ohio school district income tax is a separate levy from municipal income tax and is excluded from these figures. It is imposed by school district of residence rather than by municipality, it is unaffected by employment in North Randall Village, and no municipal credit applies to it. A resident of Cleveland whose school district levies one owes it in addition to everything shown here, which is why the totals on this page are a municipal position rather than a complete local one.
- Only municipal income tax is modeled. Ohio's state income tax, federal income tax and payroll taxes all apply in addition and are invariant to the boundary between Cleveland and North Randall Village, which is precisely why they are excluded: isolating the layer that responds to the commute is the point of the comparison. A complete tax position requires adding them; a comparison of the two locations does not.
- Dollar figures are computed against a stated reference salary of sixty thousand rather than a municipal wage average, which no published source provides for Ohio municipalities. Both rates and the credit ceiling are proportional to income, so every figure scales linearly: the Cleveland to North Randall Village differential doubles at twice the salary and halves at half of it, and the rate relationship holds at every level. The one caveat is that whether the ceiling binds at all is itself scale-invariant here, because it too is expressed as a share of income rather than as a fixed dollar cap.
Questions people ask
Do I pay local tax twice — once where I work and once where I live?
Two claims, one partly canceled. North Randall Village takes about 2.75% because you work there, Cleveland charges about 2.5% because you live there, and the home city credits some of the first against the second.
What does crossing this boundary actually cost me?
Working across the line costs $150 a year here. The same salary earned in Cleveland would not carry it.
Is this a common enough commute to be worth modeling?
1,839 workers make it. The pairing comes from federal commuting data rather than from guesswork, and thin routes are excluded rather than estimated.
How does a resident credit allocate liability between two municipalities?
Both jurisdictions assert a claim: North Randall Village on the basis of work location at about 2.75%, Cleveland on residence at about 2.5%. The residence municipality grants a credit for tax paid to the work municipality, commonly capped as a share of income. Net liability is the residence tax less that credit, floored at zero, plus the work tax.
What is the marginal local tax cost of this commute?
Marginal annual liability attributable to working outside the residence jurisdiction is $150 at the reference salary. This is a tax cost rather than a commuting expense and is not deductible as one. It scales with income and with the rate differential, not with distance traveled.
What is the basis for including this route?
Route volume is 1,839 workers, sourced from Census LODES origin-destination data. Pairs below the publication threshold are excluded rather than imputed, so page existence reflects measured commuting volume.